top of page
Search

Preparing Financial Statements for Legal Proceedings: What Attorneys Expect

When a legal matter involves money—divorce, a partner dispute, a lawsuit—your financial statements need to be more than “close enough.” They need to be clean, consistent, and easy to verify.


This article explains what “court-ready” usually means, which reports are commonly requested, and how to prep your books so your attorney or advisors can work faster (and with fewer follow-up questions).This is educational content, not legal advice—always follow counsel and court instructions.


Preparing financial statements for legal proceedings


Preparing Financial Statements for Legal Proceedings: What “Court-Ready” Means


“Court-ready” doesn’t mean perfect. It means defensible.

 

A good standard is: can someone trace your numbers from financial statements → general ledger → source documents without guessing?

 

Court-ready financials usually have:

 

  • Reconciled cash (banks/credit cards match statements)

  • One clear accounting basis (cash or accrual) used consistently

  • Clean categories (no heavy mixing of personal vs business costs)

  • A simple change log for corrections (what changed + why + support)

 

Your financials should be factual and neutral. Let your attorney handle the argument—your job is to make verification easy.


Common Legal Situations That Require Financial Statements

 

Financial statements are often required when the case needs to evaluate income, assets, debts, or damages, including:

 

  • Divorce/separation (income, support, business vs personal spending)

  • Partner/shareholder disputes (distributions, related-party payments, fairness)

  • Contract disputes/lawsuits (financial impact, timing, trend comparisons)

  • Fraud/misuse concerns (traceability and record preservation)

  • Creditor pressure (cash position, payables, ability to pay)

 

The common theme: the cleaner the books, the less time (and cost) spent proving basics.


Which Financial Statements to Prepare (and What Lawyers Ask For)

 

Most legal requests boil down to three questions: profit, position, and cash.

 

Core package:

 

  • Profit & Loss (P&L) – usually monthly for trend clarity

  • Balance Sheet – assets, liabilities, equity

  • Cash Flow statement (sometimes) – helpful when “profit ≠ cash”

 

Supporting reports (often required):

 

  • General Ledger (GL) – transaction-level detail

  • Trial Balance – quick full-account snapshot

  • AR/AP aging – who owes you / who you owe

  • Bank + credit card statements – proof of cash activity

  • Payroll summaries – wages, taxes, benefits

  • Owner draws/distributions detail – especially for owner-led businesses

 

Before exporting, confirm: time period, entities, basis (cash/accrual), and level of detail (monthly vs annual).


Getting the Books Clean: The Pre-Legal Close Checklist

 

Use this checklist to make your financials review-ready.

 

1) Define scope


Entities included, reporting period, cash vs accrual, and any class/project splits


2) Reconcile the “anchors”

 

  • Bank accounts

  • Credit cards

  • Loans/LOCs (principal vs interest)

  • Payroll liabilities

  • Merchant processors (Stripe/Square/PayPal)

 

3) Fix obvious coding issues


  • Reclass miscategorized transactions

  • Separate personal vs business spending

  • Flag unusual or large items for explanation

 

4) Validate balance sheet accounts


  • AR is real and collectible (clean up old items)

  • AP includes all bills (avoid missing liabilities)

  • Owner equity/draws are consistent

  • Clear treatment for deposits, prepaids, accruals

 

5) Create a review pack


Monthly P&L + Balance Sheet, Trial Balance, GL, reconciliation reports, AR/AP aging

 

6) Keep an adjustment log


Date, account, amount, reason, and link to support


Documentation That Must Support the Numbers

 

Financial statements without backup create delays. Build a “support folder” that makes review simple.


Documentation That Must Support the Numbers

 

Key source docs:

 

  • Bank + credit card statements

  • Invoices/receipts and contracts

  • Vendor bills + proof of payment

  • Payroll reports

  • Merchant processor reports (deposits/fees/chargebacks)

  • Loan statements and lease agreements

 

Workpapers to include:


  • Reconciliation reports

  • AR/AP schedules (with notes on old/disputed items)

  • Adjustment log (what changed and why)

 

Best practice: don’t delete history. Correct with entries and document the changes.


Normalizing, Adjusting, and Explaining One-Time Items

 

Legal reviews often ask, “What’s the real ongoing performance?” That’s why normalization matters.

 

Common one-time items:

 

  • Large legal fees/settlements

  • Emergency repairs

  • Insurance proceeds

  • Unusual owner expenses run through the business

  • Non-recurring projects

 

How to handle them cleanly:

 

  • Keep original transactions (don’t hide them)

  • Reclass to a clearly labeled bucket (e.g., “Non-recurring”)

  • Write a short note: what it was + why it’s one-time + support

 

If you adjust timing (cash vs accrual), document the basis and keep the entry log.


Special Issues: Divorce, Partner Disputes, Fraud, Financial Distress

 

Some cases trigger extra scrutiny:

 

Divorce

 

  • Biggest issues: personal/business mixing, owner draws, irregular income

  • Helpful: clean separation + monthly reporting + clear owner transaction tracking

 

Partner/shareholder disputes

 

  • Focus areas: distributions, related-party transactions, allocations by project/entity

  • Helpful: distribution ledger + support for related-party payments

 

Fraud/misuse

 

  • Priority: preserve records and keep a clean audit trail

  • Avoid deleting/editing history without logs; save exports and statements

 

Creditor pressure

 

  • Focus areas: true cash, complete liabilities, realistic receivables

  • Helpful: reconciled cash + clean AR/AP aging with notes


Avoid These Mistakes When Preparing Financial Statements for Legal Proceedings

 

These are the issues that most often trigger delays, extra legal fees, or credibility questions:

 

  • Sending unreconciled financials: If bank/credit card balances don’t match statements, everything else becomes questionable.


  • Mixing cash vs accrual without saying so: A P&L can look very different depending on method. Always label the basis clearly.


  • Changing categories mid-period: Reclassing is fine, but inconsistent mapping makes trends hard to trust. Keep categories stable.


  • Deleting transactions instead of correcting them: Deletions without an audit trail can look like manipulation. Use adjusting entries and keep a log.


  • No support folder (or support is scattered): Review slows to a crawl if documents aren’t organized by period and account.


  • Leaving personal expenses in business accounts: This is a major red flag in divorce and partner disputes. Separate and document.


  • Overstated AR or understated AP: Old receivables that won’t be collected and missing bills distort the balance sheet.


  • Forgetting “hidden” cash accounts: Merchant processors, PayPal, and secondary bank accounts must be included and reconciled.


  • Providing conclusions instead of facts: Stick to reporting and documentation. Let attorneys/experts draw legal or valuation conclusions.


When to Involve a Bookkeeper vs. CPA vs. Forensic Accountant (and How to Collaborate)

 

The fastest legal prep happens when each professional stays in their lane and shares a clean, organized file set.

 

When a bookkeeper is the right first step

 

Bring in bookkeeping support when you need:

 

  • Account clean-up and reconciliations

  • Correct transaction coding (especially personal vs business separation)

  • Reliable monthly P&L / Balance Sheet packages

  • Organized documentation folders + an adjustment log

 

Goal: make the books consistent and traceable so others can review without rework.

 

When you need a CPA

 

A CPA is useful when the matter involves:

 

  • Tax alignment questions (payroll vs distributions, deductible items, multi-year consistency)

  • Formal reporting needs (depending on what’s required and appropriate)

  • Complex accounting judgments (revenue recognition, debt, entity structure implications)

 

Goal: ensure financial treatment and documentation hold up under higher technical scrutiny.

 

When to involve a forensic accountant

 

Consider forensic support when there’s:


  • Alleged fraud, concealment, or missing records

  • Tracing funds across accounts/entities

  • Disputed income, commingling, or hidden cash activity

  • A need for expert-style analysis or testimony

 

Goal: independently analyze, trace, and explain financial activity in a way built for disputes.

 

How to collaborate efficiently (simple workflow)

 

1.     Attorney sets scope: periods, entities, format requirements

2.     Bookkeeper cleans and reconciles: prepares the reporting pack

3.     CPA/forensic reviews: requests targeted support and performs higher-level analysis

4.     One shared folder: statements, GL/TB, recs, AR/AP, payroll, adjustment log

 

This reduces duplicate work and keeps the story consistent across everyone involved.



Preparing financial statements for legal proceedings is less about fancy reports and more about clean books, consistent methods, and strong documentation. If you’d like help getting your financials reconciled, organized, and ready for review, WSC Accounting can support you with book clean-up, monthly reporting, and documentation packages tailored for attorney and advisor review.



Comments

bottom of page